As has also been noted by Armando, myself, and others, this situation closely parallels the Supreme Court case of Youngstown Sheet and Tube v. Sawyer, in which the Court ruled that if, in the legislative history of an act, Congress examines and decides in the final legislation against granting a particular power to the Executive Branch, that power is effectively denied to the Executive, and if the Executive assumes that power, it is acting extralegally.
I say we sue the bastards in a massive class action. How we do that and what obstacles such a suit might face are detailed after the break.
Cross-posted at Daily Kos, but as with many more technical diaries, it got pushed off the front page in about five minutes.
Bob Matsui was not only chairman of the DCCC; he was also chairman of the Social Security Subcommittee of the Committee on Ways and Means. He would have been our point man in the House on the issue. And he was perfectly prepared to be that point man. Matsui was probably more knowledgeable than any other Democrat in the House on the subject; he was well-respected among his peers on both sides of the aisle despite the fact that he was a fighter and would never have wavered on the issue. He was just the guy we needed.
· Blanche Lincoln's website supports public option (desmoinesdem)
· Big Coal's PR Spending Spree (desmoinesdem)
· IA-03: Former college wrestling coach to challenge Boswell (desmoinesdem)
· Tea Baggers Target Gore... (Cliff Schecter)
· Stimulus Watch (Jerome Armstrong)
· CREW seeks ethics inquiry of Bachmann (desmoinesdem)
· Did IRC help? (MN Campaign Report)
· 5 Worst cities for urban youth (desmoinesdem)
· "The Bishops' Huge Financial Stake in Stupak-Pitts" (desmoinesdem)
· Conservative group wants FEC to override state laws on robocalls (desmoinesdem)
· URGENT: Call these House Ds Saturday to oppose Stupak amendment (desmoinesdem)
· WI-08: Wingnut plans to run as "conservative independent" (desmoinesdem)